Literary Musings - "AED" or "Abrupt Ending Disorder"

Friday, September 5, 2014



It seems like the more and more I read the Young Adult genre, the more often I come across AED. No, not automatic external defibrillator – which I happen to be certified in – but what I like to call “Abrupt Ending Disorder.” For some reason, so many authors seem to get a kick out of leaving us hanging or wondering what happened after the story. I get that this might be an attempt to get us to think about the book after we finish turning the final few pages, and while I can have a healthy respect for that, I think that there’s an uncanny amount of YA books out there that just feel like the last few chapters were left out when it went to the publisher. 

Now, I can forgive – at least to some degree – cliffhangers, as long as they aren’t the final book in a series. But if your novel is standalone or the final in a series, there BETTER be some sort of resolution. More often than not, instead of coming across as artsy, all “look, I’m going to leave it here so you can interpret the ending,” you’re just going to piss your audience off. We want to know what happened to that star-struck romance – did they live happily ever after? We want to know whether or not that war-torn country rebuilt themselves after that major, tide-turning battle. But no, we’re left with the author just going, “Eh, I’m just going to finish this up in the next few pages. To hell with resolution.” 

And, yes, I realize that I might sound a little irritated. That’s because I am. I’m tired of reading a 330+ page book, only to be left with literary equivalent of the middle finger. And who, you might ask, am I thinking of while I write this? Basically Lauren Oliver and Rainbow Rowell. 

To be fair, all of Lauren Oliver’s book didn’t end so abruptly. I’m a huge fan of her Delirium trilogy; it remains today as one of my all-time favorite dystopians – and with the amount of dystopians that have flooded the market the past few years, that’s saying something. But you can’t spend years building up to a final installment of a series, only to give the readers some half-thrown together excuse for an ending. I was soooo upset with how Requiem ended. So many unanswered questions! Did Lena patch things up with her significant other? Did the final battle against the government succeed? These are major questions the audience wants to know! But will we ever get the answer? Likely not.  Thanks a lot, Lauren. Way to ruin an awesomely epic series with a lame-ass ending.

Want to know what’s even worse than that? Reading a 330+ page novel full of only romance, then getting no resolution. Ugh! I love Rainbow Rowell, don’t get me wrong, both Eleanor and Park and Fangirl were very cute reads, and I enjoyed the characters. But… You just can’t write a whole book building up a romance, then not give us a definitive answer on what happens! All we know at the end of Eleanor and Park is that Park gets a card from her- that consists of three words – and WE DON’T EVEN KNOW WHAT THOSE WORDS ARE! Really, Rainbow? Really? I felt so cheated by the end of the book. Fangirl was a little better. I was satisfied with the romance aspect, but just as soon as the characters get together, BAM – end of story. We get no, after-hook-up fluffiness. I just left me feeling a little… empty inside, I guess. The sad part is, both Rainbow’s YA books would’ve been five star reads from me, had she wrapped the stories up a little neater. 

What about you? Do you agree with my little rant? Have you come across any other authors that suffer from “AED?” Feel free to let me know what you think – or which books to avoid reading that fall into this particular scheme.

8 comments :

  1. I was actually really happy with the ending of 'Fangirl'. I'm not fond of the fluffiness that comes after the hook-up; I'm more of the "great, you hooked up, now go away" type of person lol. However, I completely agree with you on the end of 'Requiem'. I mean, we don't even know for sure who Lena ends up choosing!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Haha, you're too funny. I agree, Fangirl definitely had a better ending than some others, but... I just wanted more Cath and Levi. They had so many issues getting together that I kinda wanted to enjoy them a little while longer before the ending.

    But yes - that Requiem ending. D:< I think we should petition to have Oliver write up a few more chapters - at least tell us whether or not she ended up with him! Gah!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Requiem was the worst. It left me wondering what the point of the trilogy was in the first place, considering there is no definite resolution to ANYTHING that the story is about. It was almost like there could have been a fourth book!
    Eleanor and Park irritated me a little bit too.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It really was. :/ It was such a shame, too, cause I remember it being one of the most anticipated book of that year. Such a disappointing ending to such a great series. *Sigh*

      Delete
  4. Preach it xD
    (I was tempted for a moment to just leave that as my comment but I figure I should elaborate more, so)
    ELEANOR & PARK. THAT ENDING. *forces self to turn off caps lock*
    So I get it, not all romances end happily. That's fine, it's realistic. But it would be pretty cool if Rowell would make it clear what happens! I don't know about other people, but I don't always pick up books so I can get all philosophical with my thoughts about love and life and loss. I also read books because I want to be invested in the characters and their stories, because I sincerely want to know what happens to them. Ahem.

    Requiem's ending was also super disappointing. It was almost like Lauren Oliver didn't want to write a decision that would anger part of her fans, so she just left it up to interpretation or something...

    I'm now realizing that I have a lot to say on this topic, maybe I should do my own post about it, haha. But anyway, fantastic post, I really enjoyed this :D

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, I was so upset by the ending of E&P. Like you said, I realize that not all romances are fairy tales and end perfectly, but when I read, I read to escape all that. I don't want to read something that reminds me of how terrible ordinary, every day relationships can be. And, of course, like you I want to be invested in the characters. And I was with E&P, at least up until the ending. >.>;

      Exactly! If you're going to spend so much time building up two different romances, you at least need to deliver on it. *Sigh*

      And you definitely should. ;) We'll make "AED" a household (er, blogisphere) name.

      Delete
  5. I totally agree with you !
    This really pisses me off, and I get really mad at authors when they do this, it's just not fair !! XD

    ReplyDelete
  6. Yeah, it's definitely irritating - especially if it's a book you were really looking forward to. >:(

    ReplyDelete